| 2016 OHSAA Regional Dual Team Tournament: Division III - Region 21-B Quarterfinals - Caldwell MS |
| Wednesday, January 27 |
| Match 1 |
| Garaway 35 - West Muskingum 39 |
| 113 Wayne Kandel 12 (Garaway) Forfeit |
| 120 Kaileb Brettrager 9 (West Muskingum) dec. Dillon Rothacher 11 (Garaway) 6-3 |
| 126 Christopher Knaup 11 (West Muskingum) pin Ben Koshmider 11 (Garaway) 4:30 |
| 132 Jesse Harter 11 (West Muskingum) pin Lucas Maurer 11 (Garaway) 4:47 |
| 138 Christian Wright 9 (Garaway) tech. fall Zach Mason 10 (West Muskingum) 16-1 |
| 145 Jonathan Junk 12 (West Muskingum) pin Cameron Schlabach 9 (Garaway) 1:43 |
| 152 Kaden Bugglin 12 (West Muskingum) pin Kory Stress 9 (Garaway) 2:24 |
| 160 Grant Hershberger 11 (Garaway) pin Andrew Daulton 11 (West Muskingum) 3:43 |
| 170 Jerrod Hunt 11 (Garaway) pin Caul Smith 11 (West Muskingum) 0:36 |
| 182 Weston Woods 11 (Garaway) pin Josh Stackhouse 9 (West Muskingum) 1:07 |
| 195 Corey Taylor 12 (West Muskingum) pin Matthew Honaker 12 (Garaway) 1:21 |
| 220 Sheldon Harter 9 (West Muskingum) pin Hunter Hostetler 11 (Garaway) 3:19 |
| 285 Josh Liggett 12 (Garaway) pin Brendan Partin 11 (West Muskingum) 2:29 |
| Match 2 |
| Tuscar. Valley 22 - Caldwell 56 |
| 106 Marshal Niswonger 9 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 113 Levi Pemberton 10 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 120 Dalton Wheeler 9 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 126 Nevan Shedron 12 (Tuscar. Valley) maj. dec. Adam Schockling 11 (Caldwell) 13-4 |
| 132 Tommy Mitchell 9 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 138 Kolby Rayner 12 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 145 Leland Hostetler 12 (Tuscar. Valley) pin Blake Pickenpaugh 11 (Caldwell) 1:01 |
| 152 Jason Allen 11 (Caldwell) maj. dec. Austin Croto 10 (Tuscar. Valley) 14-4 |
| 160 Cody Davis 11 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 170 Hunter Watt 12 (Tuscar. Valley) pin Mason Wiley 9 (Caldwell) 1:53 |
| 182 Peter Hopwood 11 (Tuscar. Valley) Forfeit |
| 195 Austin Cobb 12 (Caldwell) maj. dec. Adam Kohler 12 (Tuscar. Valley) 10-0 |
| 220 Clay Poling 12 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 285 Chance Rucker 12 (Caldwell) pin Dillon Collins 11 (Tuscar. Valley) 1:27 |
| Match 3 |
| West Muskingum 32 - Caldwell 45 |
| 106 Marshal Niswonger 9 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 113 Levi Pemberton 10 (Caldwell) Forfeit |
| 120 Kaileb Brettrager 9 (West Muskingum) dec. Dalton Wheeler 9 (Caldwell) 13-7 |
| 126 Christopher Knaup 11 (West Muskingum) tech. fall Adam Schockling 11 (Caldwell) 19-3 |
| 132 Jesse Harter 11 (West Muskingum) pin Tommy Mitchell 9 (Caldwell) 3:39 |
| 138 Blake Pickenpaugh 11 (Caldwell) pin Zach Mason 10 (West Muskingum) 0:50 |
| 145 Kolby Rayner 12 (Caldwell) dec. Jonathan Junk 12 (West Muskingum) 4-3 |
| 152 Kaden Bugglin 12 (West Muskingum) pin Jason Allen 11 (Caldwell) 4:48 |
| 160 Cody Davis 11 (Caldwell) pin Andrew Daulton 11 (West Muskingum) 0:19 |
| 170 Mason Wiley 9 (Caldwell) pin Caul Smith 11 (West Muskingum) 3:48 |
| 182 Josh Stackhouse 9 (West Muskingum) pin Christian Ingram 12 (Caldwell) 1:50 |
| 195 Corey Taylor 12 (West Muskingum) Forfeit |
| 220 Clay Poling 12 (Caldwell) pin Sheldon Harter 9 (West Muskingum) 1:09 |
| 285 Chance Rucker 12 (Caldwell) pin Brendan Partin 11 (West Muskingum) 0:51 |